Bahasa Punan Bah [Ba']: Satu Rintisan Awalan is a research on Punan [Ba] but the data is Penan


UPDATED. "Bahasa Punan Bah [Ba']: Satu Rintisan Awalan" is grossly misleading for one main reason. The survey data actually collected among the Penan near Bintulu. Locally they are known as "Penan Batu 12". 

Simply put, it is akin to do a research about Iban (Sea Dayak), but then went on to gather data from a Bidayuh (Land Dayak) village. 

Furthermore, the Penan community at Batu 12 actually prefer to speak the Melanau Bintulu or Vaie dialect instead of Penan. Many in fact, identified themselves as 'Vaie'. Therefore, unsuspecting researcher would end up collected a mashup of languages - Penan, Vaie and Punan wordlist. 

No amateur researchers

Those involved in this research are amateurs - but professors and lecturer at local universities. As such, Punan National Association (PNA) was compelled to highlight the critical error in the paper. A letter was sent out to the the professors and lectures involved.

The lead author said she had requested the paper to be retracted in a letter. However, it is still widely circulated online, for example here at this  Malaysian Citation - accessed on 1/2/2020. The original link was here at UNIMAS.

Do please avoid citing the paper in your academic practice. PNA letter is attached below.

PNA letter to UMS
PNA complaint letter to Universiti Malaysia Sabah (UMS)


Popular posts from this blog

The peacemaking history between Orang Ulu and the Dayak Iban in the Rejang

Image
Photo of the Peace-Making held in Kapit 1924 There were two peace-making ceremonies held between 1907-1924 period at Kapit. The first was held in November 1907. It involved only the Upper Rejang communities and Iban along the Rejang. Among those present were the chiefs of Punan, Kayan, Kajaman, and Lahanan. Here is report by the Resident of Kapit H.S.B Johnson on December 4. 1907 (SG 1907 Dec 4, 1907:266-7): I have the honour to inform Your Highness that a successful peace-making and pig killing was brought off last Wednesday the 30th ultimo between the different Kayan tribes and the Ulu Ai Dyaks. The following Dyaks among others were present at the ceremony and agreed to make peace. Penghulu Meroom, Penghulu Narok, Penghulu Matahari, Kanian, Jimbun, Ayom, Bair, Jalin, Ajut, Pilai, Blikau, Melintang, Inggu, Koh, Kilau, Bawi, Bala. The different upriver tribes were represented by the following: Laki Boh (Kayan), Abun Batu (Kayan), Abun (Skapan), Tama Ludu (Kajaman), Oyong Seng (Lahanan)...
Read more

The Kajang of Belaga Sarawak

Image
Penghulu Puso Abun with his second wife   This article is not about the " Kajang tribe of South Sulewasi " nor the Kajang city in Selangor .   It is about tribal peoples of other islands in the South East Asia archipelago. The Kajang concerned here is a grouping of six minorities that include the Sekapans, Kejamans, Lahanans, Punans, Tanjongs, and Kanowits. They are a citizen of Sarawak, one of the Malaysian states on the island of Borneo refer to the Federal Constitution Section 161A(7) [pdf] . Kajang historical background Before 1949, no one knows about ' Kajang ', although the term has a certain currency deep in the interior of Sarawak. It was anthropologist Dr Ronald Edmund Leach who first coined the term in his “Social Economic Survey of Sarawak” report (Leach 1950:54–5). It was social economic survey commissioned by the Colonial Social Science Research Council published by His Majesty's Stationery Office in 1950. Leach's sources were the Sekapans of...
Read more

Surreal experience receiving message from great grandnephew of Bintulu Resident in 19th century

Image
FIG. 1 - George Gueritz in this photo dated 1879. Courtesy of William Gueritz.   I never anticipate what I write would be read by anyone, let alone the descendant of the people mentioned. It was due to the sheer pleasure of simply writing it . But let's me share a story what happened recently. On the other side of the world, a few thousand kilometers away - to be exact some 11,291 km away as crow flies – someone stumbled upon this post. He was researching a family history on the internet and he chanced upon this ‘Tuan Goret and Tuan Kiput’.    Around 2.13 am (local time) he sent a message to my inbox. Yeah, everything is incredibly precise this day and could be tracked! It reads,  My name is William Gueritz, I have recently been doing some (Google) research into my family's history and I came across the Punan Rights BlogSpot and the post about 'Tuan Goret', George Gueritz. You can imagine that the post intrigued me as George Gueritz is/was a relative of mine - my gr...
Read more